THE Hereford Times has won a court challenge to name a high ranking SAS soldier facing assault charges. An order banning any identification of Dale John Loveridge was overturned at Hereford Magistrates Court on Thursday.
The banning order was imposed at an earlier hearing and challenged by the Hereford Times as unlawful. At this morning's hearing solicitors for Loveridge, aged 46, made a written submission saying the order should stand because their client was "a high ranking member of the SAS" and that the disclosure of his details may "jeopardise his personal safety and his career."
The submission also said the publication of such details could compromise the administration of justice with Loveridge "not able to play an active role in proceedings" if his over-riding concern was one of personal security. At the earlier hearing Loveridge's defence raised the issue of his being "embarrasssed" by the publication of identification and case details as a reason to sustain the ban. In court, the Hereford Times argued that magistrates did not have the authority to make Loveridge the subject of such an order, which, on the evidence presented, went against established principles of open justice.
In overturning the order, District Judge Grego referred to existing case law cited by the Hereford Times to rule that "substanstial risk" to proceedings had not been demonstrated.
The risjk of prejudice to a defendant because of proceedings brought against a defendant was, said Judge Grego, the price paid for open justice and the benefits to society that outweigh the impact upon the individual.
"In any event, that prejudice is displaced by a fair trial at which, on the evidence, the defendant is found guilty or not guilty," he said.
Loveridge, who's address has been given to the court as Stirling Lines, Credenhill, faces trial next week on two charges of assault.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here